I have this mascara in blackest black. The color is super dark. I’m on my second tube of this and have never had a problem with clumping. When I want to look my absolute best, I use this mascara. It makes my lashes very long and full. It comes in regular and waterproof. Waterproof is a must for me. It does tend to flake a little, but that’s only after wearing it for the majority of the day. There’s no such thing as the perfect mascara, but for me this one is pretty close.
You can find this at Walmart and most drugstores. I can’t remember where I bought mine, but I paid about $6.